Refusing treatment: an individual right or a public health risk?

22 views
1 support
3 comments

Somya.P

Community manager

09/29/2024 at 8:00 PM

Good advisor

Somya.P

Community manager

Last activity on 06/17/2025 at 2:50 PM

Joined in 2023

647 comments posted | 232 in the Good to know group

22 of their responses were helpful to members

Rewards

Good Advisor
Contributor
Messenger
Explorer
Friend

View profileView Add a friendAdd Write

Hello everyone,

How are you today?

The refusal of medical care, where patients with chronic illnesses choose not to follow recommended treatments (for example, during COVID-19), has sparked some really heated debates.

Some view it as an individual right to autonomy and personal choice, while others highlight the risks to public health, the possibility of preventable complications, and increased healthcare costs. This topic raises important ethical and practical questions about balancing personal freedom and collective responsibility.

@duznot19 @Lovaann @Blancagirl @Watkins84 @VanillaCheerios @TerresaG @Shiningstarspc @Breathenow @jbabor @Wave66 @Charrell10835 @lourdesr @ljaronson @Dolores50 @Jlknight @Lyndajay @croleyandy @Kmil780750r @mtdurkin @patriciadurkin902 @Jackie63 @Elk217015 @Cathy1956 @Painful311 @Krisnbill @spot24spot @Janell12965 @Realife @kunderhill @SuzieLooWho @Desdak @Victorialove @Sabrinamaddin @Mark-IL @Barb440 @LadyRooster @tbloemendal @Msmurrayv @Ellendr @Erickabarone @Chelsea @Titi123456 @jamieolmedo16 @Germ63 @sylvesr174 @Jujuhorn @Calflash @Mrn001a @ymgura @BecyM1966 @Lorettab @joanne59 @Dayholden @DinaNash @Blanchebecker @Joannek @swc828 @Medman @KurtForry @Skinnyliver @Karenenox @Lejocos40 @MonyaBarnes @DonLeBlanc @cfraz1932 @MyMS55 @JollyShirley @Marken13 @adgoodsel @Tbeans98 @brwnsgr38 @Tdmspencer @pfletcher490 @Rmattox @Mamouska @Ali1959 @Jordan24 @PinkCarnation24 @Paige## @TomTilkey @Lindamcgurk @Cbrewer456 @Robertamc @champmom1059 @BrookeShiffi @Silbear @Nicci421 @PattiSample @flutterbye21 @mheilman5770 @parexcell3 @Jermian @fposner @Gmamoe19 @Volfan47 @Tinxgma @Miriamargi @crock.99 @Aziza!2018 @nikki1974

Have you ever refused treatment or care recommended for your chronic illness? If so, what were your reasons? How do you see the balance between a patient's right to refuse treatment and their responsibility to their own health and society as a whole?

Looking forward to hearing your thoughts below!

Take care and have a great day,
Somya from the Carenity team 🌼

All comments

Silbear

09/29/2024 at 10:22 PM

Silbear

Last activity on 05/07/2025 at 5:13 AM

Joined in 2020

2 comments posted | 1 in the Good to know group

Rewards

Explorer

View profileView Add a friendAdd Write

I did not go to a referral but I called the office and spoke to the Dr and he said I can wait until I get another blood test. And exam. The cardiologist had seen me last fall and I think my Dr forgot that I saw him.

Refusing treatment: an individual right or a public health risk? https://www.carenity.us/forum/other-discussions/good-to-know/refusing-treatment-an-individual-right-or-a-public-health-risk-5863 2024-09-29 22:22:09

Shiningstarspc

Edited on 09/30/2024 at 6:42 PM

Shiningstarspc

Last activity on 06/16/2025 at 11:50 AM

Joined in 2019

1 comment posted | 1 in the Good to know group

1 of their responses was helpful to members

Rewards

Explorer

View profileView Add a friendAdd Write

Each person has the right to make their own health choices, and we must honor that. As someone who didn't receive the COVID-19 vaccine, I stand firm in my decision. At the time, I was considered high-risk due to brain lesions, yet when I contracted COVID, I recovered in just one day with minor symptoms, staying home and isolating responsibly. My choice didn't harm anyone, and in fact, I've been much healthier since. I know many who took the vaccine and suffered severe side effects, with some even losing their lives shortly after. Whether there's a connection is still up for debate. What’s clear is that health isn't one-size-fits-all.

I prioritize my wellness through prebiotics, probiotics, and other alternative methods. Despite being told I had only six months to live over six years ago, I’ve thrived by following my own path. We each need to evaluate what’s best for our unique bodies. Medications may not be for everyone, and they’re not right for me right now. I've found alternative ways to maintain my health and will continue to evolve in my journey. Like anything, health requires focus and periodic adjustments. I’m continuously learning and adapting to optimize my well-being.

Ultimately, each of us has the right to choose our own health plan—whether through mainstream or alternative methods. No single approach works for everyone. My path includes stem cell activation, grounding, and a whole-body approach, and it has empowered me to live beyond expectations. This is my plan, and I’m proud of it. We all deserve the freedom to find what works for us.

Close all

See the responses

Somya.P

Community manager

10/22/2024 at 8:37 PM

Good advisor

Somya.P

Community manager

Last activity on 06/17/2025 at 2:50 PM

Joined in 2023

647 comments posted | 232 in the Good to know group

22 of their responses were helpful to members

Rewards

Good Advisor
Contributor
Messenger
Explorer
Friend

View profileView Add a friendAdd Write

Hi @Shiningstarspc,

Thank you for sharing such a personal and empowering story. You’ve clearly given a lot of thought to your health decisions, with how well you’ve navigated your own journey. Everyone’s body reacts differently, and it’s important to recognize those unique experiences. How do you balance your lifestyle when it comes to health, especially with the many different alternative methods you’re using?

Take care,
Somya from the Carenity Team 🌼

See the signature

Somya from the Carenity team

Hide the responses

Refusing treatment: an individual right or a public health risk?

All comments

Give your opinion

What do you think about the Carenity Forum and community?

Help shape the future of Carenity!

Articles to discover...